FLORIDA
Cape Coral Dining Guide: 12 Essential Restaurants, From Waterfront Classics to New Favorites
By Eric Barton | Oct. 22, 2025
Gather
AUTHOR BIO: Eric Barton is editor of The Adventurist and a freelance journalist who has reviewed restaurants for more than two decades. Email him here.
I started coming to Cape Coral in the ’90s because my college roommate was from here, back when dinner usually meant a basket of something fried and a view that did more work than the kitchen. Those early trips were great for sunsets, less so for menus. You learned quickly which fish houses nailed a crispy grouper sandwich and which ones were better for a bucket of beers.
Now the city cooks like it means it. There are waterfront spots still doing right by the Gulf, and there are chef-driven rooms downtown shaking big-city cocktails and sending out plates with an actual point of view. The result is a scene that rewards regulars and makes a weekend detour feel smart.
What follows is my personal list of Cape Coral’s best restaurants, curated over decades of meals, notes, and return visits.
Cork Soakers Deck & Wine Bar
$$$$$ | MAP | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM
Cork Soakers is the South Cape hangout with a breezy deck, live music, and a kitchen led by chef Gary Pfenning for owners Bob and Lina Mulroy. The menu skews comfort-forward—think chicken and dumplings, lobster mac, a prime rib sandwich, and seared-salmon risotto—plus a Sunday brunch that packs the patio. Drinks lean easygoing: crowd-pleasing wines, solid cocktails, and a bar team that moves fast when the band kicks in.
Best for: A lively brunch or casual night when comfort food and a breezy deck beat white tablecloths
Fish Tale Grill by Merrick Seafood
$$$$$ | MAP | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM
Fish Tale Grill is the restaurant side of Merrick Seafood’s long-running market, which means the raw bar is the freshest you’ll find intown and the fish on the board was likely cut next door that morning. Start with the seafood tower or a dozen oysters, then pick from staples like lobster bisque, a grouper sandwich that tastes like the Gulf, or whatever the line cooks are pan-searing from today’s catch. It’s lively and built for people who like to see the market behind their dinner.
Best for: Raw bar cravings and market-fresh plates in one stop
Front Porch Social
$$$$$ | MAP | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM
Cocktail bar first, kitchen close behind: think tight drinks, a few house must-order snacks, and that friendly clatter you want from a neighborhood room. It reads casual—patio seats, pop-in vibe—but the plates and pours show real care. Settle in for a round and you’ll understand why regulars keep talking about this place like it’s their find.
Best for: Easy nights with craft drinks and shareables
Gather
$$$$$ | MAP | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM
Gather sits on Tarpon Point Marina with a calm, glassy view of masts and a kitchen run by partner/executive chef Benjamin Voisin. The menu swings from Korean-style duck wings and Ahi tuna tataki at night to a legit weekend brunch that includes a short rib Benedict and chilaquiles upgraded with wagyu tenderloin.
Best for: Waterfront brunch and linger-long cocktails
Jungle Bird Tiki
$$$$$ | MAP | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM
Jungle Bird Tiki is downtown Cape Coral’s neon-palm escape, a true tiki room with hanging greenery, carved mugs, and a playlist that keeps the room buoyant. The bar turns out balanced rum drinks—the namesake Jungle Bird with that bitter-citrus snap, plus Painkillers and Zombies poured the way you want them—while bartenders grate fresh nutmeg and squeeze juice to order. The food skews party-shareable (wings, sliders, loaded nachos) that do what they should: keep pace with the cocktails and the patio chatter.
Best for: Tiki cocktails and a lively downtown scene
Let’s Waffle
$$$$$ | MAP | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM
Owner Nadin Feix’s restaurant is the sunny, counter-service spot on Santa Barbara Boulevard built around Belgian irons and a menu that runs sweet to savory. Go classic with strawberries, bananas, and Nutella, or lean savory with chicken-and-waffles and a hit of hot honey, then chase it with a latte while the next batch hisses on the griddle. It’s quick, kid-friendly, and the weekend line moves because the crew keeps those irons working.
Best for: Family-friendly brunch built around sweet-to-savory waffles
Next Door
$$$$$ | MAP | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM
Tarpon Point finally got its pasta temple, with an open kitchen turning out daily dough—think silky ravioli, hand-rolled gnocchi, and those pillowy focaccia knots that vanish fast. Menus change often enough to keep locals chasing the tuna crudo one week and a deeper, richer ragù the next. The room is small, the plates are dialed-in, and the wine list reads like someone actually drinks from it.
Best for: A proper pasta night with marina views
Point 57 Kitchen & Cocktails
$$$$$ | MAP | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM
Point 57 is the date-night spot where the bar hums and the kitchen leans Southern-coastal without going fussy. Think fried green tomatoes stacked with pimento cheese, shrimp and grits with a proper Andouille bite, and a thick pork chop that lands with char and butter. The cocktails are tight—stirred classics, fresh juice, big cubes—and they drink even better on the patio when the dinner rush hits.
Best for: A polished night out with strong cocktails and Southern-leaning plates
Rumrunners
$$$$$ | MAP | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM
Rumrunners anchors Cape Harbour with marina-side tables, big windows, and slips out front for the dock-and-dine crowd. The kitchen sticks the classics—a cornflake-crusted crunchy grouper sandwich, a Cayo Costa roll with salmon and carrot-ginger dressing, plus the expected steaks and seafood—while the bar keeps the patio humming on live-music nights. It’s the spot where boaters drop in salty and couples dress up, and both feel like they picked right.
Best for: Waterfront sunsets with a crunchy grouper sandwich and a drink in hand
Sage on 47th
$$$$$ | MAP | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM
Downtown’s new hangout runs chef-driven plates and a brunch people plan their Sundays around, from lamb chops with pistachio pesto to seafood risotto and a bluefin tuna over a crispy jasmine-rice cake. The bar program isn’t an afterthought—balanced drinks, decent wine, and a staff that can actually talk you through the menu. It’s polished without pretense, which explains the steady hum at both brunch and dinner.
Best for: A lively downtown meal, at brunch or dinner
Stones Throw
$$$$$ | MAP | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM
This modern neighborhood spot on Cape Coral Parkway with the lights low, a long bar, and a menu that swings from shareables to steaks without losing the plot. You’ll see smart touches—towering burgers dripping with cheese under brioche buns, USDA Prime steaks, well-seared scallops—and a happy hour that’s become a local ritual. It feels like a gastropub built by people who eat out a lot and know what makes a plate succeed.
Best for: Legit cocktails and comfort food that lands
Twisted Lobster
$$$$$ | MAP | WEBSITE | INSTAGRAM
Twisted Lobster is the busy neighborhood seafood house on Del Prado, the kind where the line forms early and the baskets hit the table hot. The menu reads New England-by-way-of-Florida: whole belly clams and a proper lobster roll alongside lobster bisque, clam chowder, and a Gulf grouper sandwich that actually tastes like grouper. It’s first-come, loud in a good way, and exactly right when you want seafood without ceremony.
Best for: Chowder and lobster rolls in a setting that matches
From Calle Ocho to the Coast: Where Miami Really Eats, Drinks, and Plays
Beyond the velvet ropes and resort menus, here’s the insider’s guide to the city’s best restaurants and things to do.